J/MNRAS/469/2121ivo://CDS.VizieR/J/MNRAS/469/2121doi:10.26093/cds/vizier.74692121CDSSanchez S.F.Barrera-Ballesteros J.K.Sanchez-Menguiano L.Walcher C.J.,Marino R.A.Galbany L.Bland-Hawthorn J.Cano-Diaz M.Garcia-Benito R.,Lopez-Coba C.Zibetti S.Vilchez J.M.Iglesias-Paramo J.Kehrig C.,Lopez Sanchez A.R.Duarte Puertas S.Ziegler B.2024-08-17T20:19:09Z2020-05-14T07:54:56ZCDS support team

CDS, Observatoire de Strasbourg, 11 rue de l'Universite, F-67000 Strasbourg, France

cds-question@unistra.frgalaxieschemical-abundancesWe present an updated version of the mass-metallicity (MZ) relation using integral field spectroscopy data obtained from 734 galaxies observed by the CALIFA survey. These unparalleled spatially resolved spectroscopic data allow us to determine the metallicity at the same physical scale (R_e_) for different calibrators. We obtain MZ relations with similar shapes for all calibrators, once the scalefactors among them are taken into account. We do not find any significant secondary relation of the MZ relation with either the star formation rate (SFR) or the specific SFR for any of the calibrators used in this study, based on the analysis of the residuals of the best-fitted relation. However, we do see a hint for an (s)SFR-dependent deviation of the MZ relation at low masses (M<10^9.5^M_{sun}_), where our sample is not complete. We are thus unable to confirm the results by Mannucci et al. (2010), although we cannot exclude that this result is due to the differences in the analysed data sets. In contrast, our results are inconsistent with the results by Lara-Lopez et al. (2010), and we can exclude the presence of an SFR-mass-oxygen abundance fundamental plane. These results agree with previous findings suggesting that either (1) the secondary relation with the SFR could be induced by an aperture effect in single fibre/aperture spectroscopic surveys, (2) it could be related to a local effect confined to the central regions of galaxies or (3) it is just restricted to the low-mass regime, or a combination of the three effects.2017MNRAS.469.2121Shttps://cdsarc.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/cat/J/MNRAS/469/2121CatalogResearchIsServedByTAP VizieR generic serviceIsServedByConesearch servicerelated-toJ/A+A/594/A36 : CALIFA Survey DR3 list of galaxies (Sanchez+, 2016)https://cds.unistra.fr/vizier-org/licences_vizier.htmlhttps://vizier.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/VizieR-2?-source=J/MNRAS/469/2121https://vizier.iucaa.in/viz-bin/VizieR-2?-source=J/MNRAS/469/2121http://vizieridia.saao.ac.za/viz-bin/VizieR-2?-source=J/MNRAS/469/2121https://vizier.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/votable?-source=J/MNRAS/469/2121https://vizier.iucaa.in/viz-bin/votable?-source=J/MNRAS/469/2121http://vizieridia.saao.ac.za/viz-bin/votable?-source=J/MNRAS/469/2121GETtext/xml+votablehttps://tapvizier.cds.unistra.fr/TAPVizieR/tapCone search capability for table J/MNRAS/469/2121/tableb1 (Stellar Masses, star formation rates and characteristics abundances for the all the considered calibrators)https://vizier.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/conesearch/J/MNRAS/469/2121/tableb1?https://vizier.iucaa.in/viz-bin/conesearch/J/MNRAS/469/2121/tableb1?http://vizieridia.saao.ac.za/viz-bin/conesearch/J/MNRAS/469/2121/tableb1?GETtext/xml+votable180.050000true23.323612513.33243610.0055555555555555566/43 50 56 131 471 545 552 554 568 573 620-621 627 721 733 738 907-909 948-949 975 995 1517 1596 1644 1701 2169 2206 2228-2229 2248 2250-2251 2254 2272-2274 2276 2290 2408 2561 2641 3105 3217 3519 3929 4114 4167 4178 4279 4342 4445 4454 4472 4507 4511 4526 4647 4654-4655 4667 4688 4704 4712 4716 4719 4753-4754 4772 4799 4801 4806-4807 4813 4829 4840 4843-4844 4850 4912 4950 4957 4993 5023-5024 5028 5030 5075 5115 5148 5241 5298 5332 5399 5482 5505 5530 5533 5579 5586 5591 5593 5596 5642 5648 5695 5701 5704 5757 5862 5889 5942 5951 5975 5980 5992 6000 6011 6034 6045-6046 6074 6082 6087 6093 6096 6116 6162 6212 6214 6216 6240-6241 6261 6270 6335 6342 6362 6366 6448 6465 6501 6532 6541 6547 6554 6607 6630 6805 6970 6977 6994 7014 7198-7199 7204 7214 7309 7312 7340 7386 7442 7501 7559-7560 7572 7584 7589 7591 7599 7696 7735 7783 7824 7834 7844 7849 7983 8045 8164 8195 8297 8327 8331 8341 8366 8376 8458 8477 8479-8480 8492 8498 8522 8536-8537 8552 8557 8562-8563 8570 8589 8605 8621 8646 8656 8673 8700 8705 8719 8723 8728 8743 8752 8754 8825 8883 8898 8900 8919 8921-8922 8984 8992 9098 9101 9124 9126 9133 9141 9187 9190 9216 9220 9287 9368 9381 9452 9470-9471 9622 9630 9672 9695 9718 9736 9759 9812 9859 9873 9875 9882-9883 9885 9891 9946 9974 9991 10025 10111 10113 10144 10182-10183 10189 10200 10203 10213 10220-10221 10240 10280 10286 10330 10379-10381 10400-10401 10414 10422 10434 10438 10448 10485 10501 10511-10512 10515 10518-10520 10523-10524 10530 10540 10560 10566 10570 10577 10583 10586 10588 10594-10595 10609 10612 10621 10627-10629 10637 10661-10662 10669 10674 10705 10711 10719 10721 10727 10736 10739-10740 10752 10773 10846 10921 10984 10987 11010 11026 11044 11070 11111-11112 11164 11173 11196 11272 11290 11314 11325-11326 11341 11369 11372 11377 11383 11387 11392 11396 11433 11435 11443 11451 11525 11544 11761 11777 11789 11793 11800-11801 11804 11832 11905 11944 12378 12532 12709 13128 13316 13380-13381 13401 13426 13459 13463 13496 13523 13529 13545 13780 13901 14560 14962 15002 15004 16007 16016 16091 16702 16787-16788 16793 17233-17234 17237-17238 17350 17392 17398 17486 17492 17499 17511 17516 17520 17571 17661-17663 17667 17672 17745 17747 17751 17758 17761 17767 17773 17819 17912 17998 18008 18069 18071 18081 18173 18241-18242 18252 18295 18300-18302 18381 18383 18523 18775 18779 18781 18790 18800 18838 18854 18931-18932 18935 18941 19027 19073 19084 19108 19186 19227 19260 19267 19283 19325 19387 19417 19432 19458 19487 19489 19508 19515 19537-19538 19589 19593 19618 19633 19642 19661 19678 19696 19749 19848 19897 19939-19940 19954 19981 19983-19984 19996-19997 20009 20014 20020 20023 20031-20033 20193 20254 20279 20356 20417-20418 20429 21857 21953 22353 22356 22361 22364 22651-22652 22654-22655 22737 22740-22742 22826 23051 23072 23076 23204 23206 23208 23273 23337 23353 23356 23401 23405 23895 24055 24186 25491 25715 25888-25889 26102 26108 26125 26318 26432 26451 26495 26548 26551 26563 26791 27133 27239 27259 27368 27559 27567 27596 27608 27719 27725 27729 27738 27748 27761 27767 27830 27853 27861-27862 27912 27914-27915 27938 28019 28112 28149 28213 28221 28263-28264 28294 28310 28322 28365 28430 28491 28497 28513 28522 28579 28599 28606 28617 28639 29973 30044 31218 31478 31546 31628 31642-31643 31688-31689 31735-31737 32462 32471 32478 32482 32555 32559 32614 36604 36733 36765 36793 36797 36805 36857 48880 49084 49121 49130 49150https://cdsarc.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/moc/J/MNRAS/469/2121?format=asciidefaultJ/MNRAS/469/2121/table1Fitting parameters for the MZ relation and its scatter for the set of abundance calibrators used in this studye_aError on astat.errorfloatrecnoRecord number assigned by the VizieR team. Should Not be used for identification.meta.recordintIndMetallicity indicatormeta.id;stat.fitcharsigma(O/H)Original distribution of the oxygen abundancephys.abundfloataParameter a from the fitting of equation (1) to the MZ relation (1)stat.fit.paramfloatbParameter b from the fitting of equation (1) to the MZ relation (1)stat.fit.paramfloate_bError on bstat.errorfloatsigmaMZresStandard deviation of the residuals after subtracting the best fit to the MZ relationphys.abundfloatalphaLinear fitting of the residuals of the MZ relation with respect to the SFR alpha (zero-point) parameter (see Section 4.2)stat.fit.paramfloate_alphaError on alphastat.error;pos.eq.rafloatbetaLinear fitting of the residuals of the MZ relation with respect to the SFR beta (slope) parameter (see Section 4.2)stat.fit.paramfloate_betaError on betastat.errorfloatsigmaDMZresStandard deviation of the residuals of the linear fitting using the above parametersphys.abundfloatJ/MNRAS/469/2121/tableb1Stellar Masses, star formation rates and characteristics abundances for the all the considered calibratorsSimbadNameSimbad column added by the CDSmeta.idcharrecnoRecord number assigned by the VizieR team. Should Not be used for identification.meta.recordintNameGalaxy name (CALIFA name)meta.id;meta.maincharlogMasslogarithm of the stellar masslog(solMass)phys.massdoublee_logMassError of logarithm of the stellar masslog(solMass)stat.error;phys.massdoublelogSFRlogarithm of the stellar star formationlog(solMass.yr**-1)phys.SFRdoublee_logSFR? Error of logarithm of the stellar star formationlog(solMass.yr**-1)stat.error;phys.SFRdoublenullablen_e_logSFR[i] i for infinitymeta.notecharO3N2-M13? 12+log(O/H) with O3N2-M13 calibrationphys.abunddoublenullablen_O3N2-M13[i] i for infinitymeta.notechare_O3N2-M13? Error in 12+log(O/H) with O3N2-M13 calibrationstat.errordoublenullablen_e_O3N2-M13[i] i for infinitymeta.notecharN2-M13? 12+log(O/H) with N2-M13 calibrationphys.abunddoublenullablen_N2-M13[i] i for infinitymeta.notechare_N2-M13? Error in 12+log(O/H) with N2-M13 calibrationstat.errordoublenullablen_e_N2-M13[i] i for infinitymeta.notecharONS-M13? 12+log(O/H) with ONS-M13 calibrationphys.abunddoublenullablen_ONS-M13[i] i for infinitymeta.notechare_ONS-M13? Error in 12+log(O/H) with ONS-M13 calibrationstat.errordoublenullablen_e_ONS-M13[i] i for infinitymeta.notecharR23? 12+log(O/H) with R23 own calibrationphys.abunddoublenullablen_R23[i] i for infinitymeta.notechare_R23? Error in 12+log(O/H) with R23 own calibrationstat.errordoublenullablen_e_R23[i] i for infinitymeta.notecharO3N2-PP04? 12+log(O/H) with O3N2-PP04 calibrationphys.abunddoublenullablen_O3N2-PP04[i] i for infinitymeta.notechare_O3N2-PP04? Error in 12+log(O/H) with O3N2-PP04 calibrationstat.errordoublenullablen_e_O3N2-PP04[i] i for infinitymeta.notecharpyqz? 12+log(O/H) with pyqz calibrationphys.abunddoublenullablen_pyqz[i] i for infinitymeta.notechare_pyqz? Error in 12+log(O/H) with pyqz calibrationstat.errordoublenullablen_e_pyqz[i] i for infinitymeta.notechart2? 12+log(O/H) with t2 calibrationphys.abunddoublenullablen_t2[i] i for infinitymeta.notechare_t2? Error in 12+log(O/H) with t2 calibrationstat.errordoublenullablen_e_t2[i] i for infinitymeta.notecharM08? 12+log(O/H) with M08 calibrationphys.abunddoublenullablen_M08[i] i for infinitymeta.notechare_M08? Error in 12+log(O/H) with M08 calibrationstat.errordoublenullablen_e_M08[i] i for infinitymeta.notecharT04? 12+log(O/H) with T04 calibrationphys.abunddoublenullablen_T04[i] i for infinitymeta.notechare_T04? Error in 12+log(O/H) with T04 calibrationstat.errordoublenullablen_e_T04[i] i for infinitymeta.notecharDOP? 12+log(O/H) with DOP calibrationphys.abunddoublenullablen_DOP[i] i for infinitymeta.notechare_DOP? Error in 12+log(O/H) with DOP calibrationstat.errordoublenullablen_e_DOP[i] i for infinitymeta.notecharEPM? 12+log(O/H) with EPM calibrationphys.abunddoublenullablen_EPM[i] i for infinitymeta.notechare_EPM? Error in 12+log(O/H) with EPM calibrationstat.errordoublenullablen_e_EPM[i] i for infinitymeta.notechar_RARight Ascension (J2000) from SIMBAD (not part of the original data)degpos.eq.ra;meta.mainnullable_DEDeclination (J2000) from SIMBAD (not part of the original data)degpos.eq.dec;meta.mainnullable